
Here are the horses I see as the
prime contenders to WIN the race:
13 I Want Revenge This is the fastest horse, he has won on the dirt, and he has won on both coasts. His running style fits this race and his Apr. 28 workout at Churchill was sharp. He fits the profile of previous Derby winners and is a dual qualifier (related to distance breeding and accomplishment). Only concern is 19 yr. old jockey (Talamo), but the great ones are often great early. This horse deserves to be the favorite, but 3-1 is not that attractive for a horse that has not dominated to this point like Big Brown did last year.
16 Pioneerof the Nile Another California horse that has been winning big races, but has not raced on dirt (has won on turf and poly). He was beating I Want Revenge this winter in California on poly, but his speed numbers have not improved as much since then. Tough to say how poly impacts the speed numbers. Sire Empire Maker finished 2nd to Funny Cide in the Derby and came back to beat him in the Belmont. Auxilary gate start doesn't help, but this one has a great chance if he likes dirt. Also a dual qualifier. 5-1 morning line odds looks fair.
11 Chocolate Candy Another California horse that has not raced on dirt. Doesn't have quite the record of the first two, but has been winning. Last was a close 2nd to Pioneerof the Nile at Santa Anita. He is the 3rd of 4 dual qualifiers, and I can't believe his 20-1 odds. Fits the Giacomo profile, and will be charging hard down the stretch. Strong Churchill work on Apr. 27. Definite contender.
6 Friesan Fire Yes, I am aware of horses outside of California, and this one has won on the dirt. Three straight wins in Louisiana, and an eye-popping workout on Apr. 27 at Churchill. NOT a dual qualifier, but excellent breeding and has the racing background to fit with Derby contenders. Has had an unusually long 7 week rest since last race, and making a bigger distance stretch than the other contenders. 5-1 odds, and this one would be more appealing at 8-1 or higher.
Others to consider. While I think the winner will come from my prime contenders list, this group has a legitimate chance to win or finish in the money at long odds.
10 Regal Ransom Longshot alert. This horse won at Saratoga, raced once in California, and shipped to the United Arab Emirates for the winter. He won the UAE Derby in March, and his Churchill workouts have been great. No horse has ever won the Derby shipping from the middle east, but this one has a chance. Same sire as Funny Cide, and the 30-1 odds may end up higher. Definite threat to be in the money.
7 Papa Clem Has won on dirt and poly, including quality stakes score in Arkansas last race. Doesn't quite fit the "winner" profile, but strong breeding and 2nd place finishes to Pioneer and Friesan, along with his recent stakes win, show he is competitive with this group. 20-1.
1 West Side Bernie Last of the dual qualifiers, and was 2nd last time out to I Want Revenge. Hasn't won since September and inside post position not favorable in this race. 30-1 odds make him worth a consideration, but would be a little surprised if he is a major factor.
Is there anything to like about the other 13 horses?
Yes, but not enough for me to consider risking my mint julip money. Dunkirk has top breeding and was bought for $3.7 million. He is lightly raced and doesn't fit the profile of past winners. Not worth the 4-1 odds here. I think he will be a top horse...after he gets more experience. General Quarters, Musket Man, and Advice are all coming off stakes wins, but I don't think any of them have the speed or the profile to be serious threats here. Their wins, however, have moved their odds to the 20-1 range for horses that should probably be 40-1. Hold Me Back and Mr. Hot Stuff have good trainer/jockey combinations, but just haven't run to the level of the others at this point. The other seven have too many factors against them (post position, profile, etc.) or just simply don't belong here.
A tip of the cap to The Pamplemousse who is injured, but may have been my top pick. Look for him racing later this year.
Good Luck to Everyone!